Common Divorce Myth: Mothers always get custody of the kids

Just in time for Mother’s Day, we’re going to dispel a mother-centered family law myth. In a word, the response to the notion that mothers always will get custody of the children is: Nope. Oregon statutes are gender-neutral in this regard: in fact, there’s a mandate that courts not give preference for either parent just because that parent is either the mother or the father. ORS 107.137(4).

Instead, ORS 107.137 provides a list of factors for courts to use in determining who should receive custody of the children in a divorce case. (The same factors apply to determination of custody matters when the parents aren’t married, too, via ORS 107.103.)

Roughly speaking, these factors boil down to the “best interest of the child.” More specifically, this means the court looks at the following factors, not giving undue weight to any one factor:

  • emotional ties between the child and other family members;
  • the interest of the parties in the child and their attitude toward the child;
  • the desirability of continuing an existing relationship between the child and the parties;
  • any abuse of one parent by another;
  • the preference for the primary caregiver of the child, if that person is determined to be fit;
  • the willingness and ability of each parent to facilitate and encourage a close relationship between the child and the other parent – but not where facilitating this relationship could pose a danger to the safety and health of the child.

ORS 107.103(1)(a)-(f).

Another factor not enumerated in the statutes but which has been mentioned in case law is the drug use of a parent. In Johnson and Johnson, 154 Or App 560, 962 P2d 752 (1998), the Court of Appeals (rather understatedly) held that drug use is not compatible with childrearing. Johnson at 566. In Johnson, the court also held that where a mother’s drug use was behind her and where the father had not been significantly involved in caring for the children, it would be inappropriate to shift custody from the mother to the father. Id.

In many cases, especially where both parties work and split childcare duties and there are no drug or abuse issues, these factors may not seem terribly helpful to the parties in looking at their case and in trying to work out a settlement.

Oregon encourages parties to resolve these disputes early on. Where custody is at issue, the parties are required to go through a mediation process after starting a child education program (these requirements are occasionally waived, but only for very good reasons).

If the parties still can’t agree, before the case goes to trial, either side can request a custody study be performed either through a public agency or a private expert. We’ve found private studies to be a very important tool in custody or parenting time disputes. The expert, usually a licensed clinical social worker or a psychologist, who conducts the study will do a very thorough evaluation, interviewing not only the parties and observing their interactions with the children, but also interviewing other references and delving into the background of the case. And while an expert may testify at trial, the expert’s report frequently assists the parties in settling the custody or parenting time issues prior to trial — saving clients subsequent attorney fees and costs.

This entry was posted in Child Custody, Dissolution, Myths. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Common Divorce Myth: Mothers always get custody of the kids

  1. Judy F. says:

    How many States are Gender-Neutral? Could you provide a list of those States so Mothers and Fathers can benefit from this knowledge? Also, could you comment on what some mothers refer to as “Father States”? For example, many mothers believe Illinois Judges supposedly lean toward fathers in awarding custody and lenient support–what is your perspective on this perception?

  2. Oklahoma Family Law use to allow for the ‘tender years presumption’. The presumption was abolished about 30 years ago though.

  3. I was in Mobile, Alabama when I lost custody of my 3 year old daughter Katie in 1998 after originally being awarded custody of her. There were no drugs, he had been abusive to me in the marriage and had really never bothered with her…he was having an affair, in fact she was living in the house my name was still on. What it came down to was that his first wife was bringing him back to court for more child support, plus he was paying me and his new whatever you want to call that was in arrears at about 500 a month. He started filing false charges and it began. It has been 14 years and Im finally about to go for broke and bust Mobile, Alabama WIDE OPEN. I found that down there, I was a young active duty Coast Guards woman from Boston, it was NOT good to be a Yankee, He who has the most money and old connections wins. The whole case, rather cases, they were just so dirty I wish I could show them to you. You would honestly fall over even the JUDGES were so blatant. My ex husband and daughter then basically disappeared in 2001, I didnt find out until 2007 that he had been arrested and put in federal prison for drug manufacturing. His mother took my daughter over state lines to Mississippi, Dept of Human Resources never called me. I have a lawyer, and he is about to file for custody, Katie although we had once rebuilt our bond despite the SICK things she had been told and the abuse she had endured, now honestly has a FULL BLOWN case of PAS. I know she is 17, but being a surivivor of PTSD myself and having a wonderful life, I am determined to be there for her because they wont. I just know there has to be some way to get her out there now with all they have done, to have them arrested somehow. But even after all my cases were cleared, the custody judge…it was amazing, I wanted to ask her if she was listening to the same case. It turned out she was the same judge for my ex and his new soon to be bride…and future abuser of my daughter…oh they had the same lawyer too. I would love to show it all to you, I really need to get it out there anyway..thanks for listening. My daughter deserved better than this, and I just pray to God that this is going to work. I have been waiting for it to be the right time…in his time. God bless

Leave a Reply to Kelly Costley Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *